Playing N/S with Gerry came 1st with 57.5%.
Ivan led JS, great I can finesse his 10, so I win in hand and immediately play back a small spade and Ivan shows out! I took the Ace and decided to ensure my 10 tricks rather than gamble on hearts, so I played K then Q of diamonds and Helen took that with her Ace. She now surprised me with KH. After the singleton spade lead and no real values in the minors I suspected Ivan had good hearts. I even thought this King was singleton Anyway I took my Ace and led back a heart. Ivan paused, good, eventually played low and I won the Jack. I now played 9S, covered and won in hand and Ivan let a club go. Everything looks rosy now and with 4 spades, 4 clubs, 2 hearts and 2 diamonds I had 12 tricks.
Gerry opened 1C, I bid 1D and Ivan came in 2S. Gerry bid 2N which came round to me. You hate to play in a minor at Pairs but I was unsure. Temporising I bid a checkback 3C and Gerry bid 3H. I decided that made it a little less likely that Gerry had a double spade stop and I bid 5C.
Double dummy we can see that running 8D is a sure way to 12 tricks, but not a likely way to play it. Gerry won the spade lead, ruffed a spade, diamond to the Q, ruffed a spade. He now drew trumps and finessed 10H. Now came a small diamond. If Ivan takes the Ace then diamonds are set up. He ducked and Helen won, but she is end played as a diamond exit will see Ivan's Ace ruffed and dummy's diamonds are good and a heart exit is a free finesse. A much neater way of making 12 tricks.
Mike opened East 1C and Michele bid 4S. What do I lead? If we discount AC is a red suit a good lead? Maybe 6D was correct, but I figured Michele for 7 good, probably 8 spades and I have 3. Is a spade lead going to lose partner a trick, I thought unlikely and led 3S. Could not have been worse. Yes it did cost a spade trick and not leading the diamond lost us that as well. Instead of 1 down it was plus 1. Gerry won AS and returned a small club looking for a diamond but I couldn't see the point as she will be forced to win Ace and discard diamonds on clubs. I just returned a club. Michele won this, threw a diamond and ruffed a club with 10S. That gave her the rest.
Cliff found the perfect lead of JD. If they are 4-4 and AC onside I can still make this, however I can't let them take two diamonds then switch to hearts. So I won AD, ran all my spades but to no avail, even with AC onside they had 4 diamond tricks.
Interestingly what If I do hold up? I can't see Cliff finding a heart switch. So if I had won the third diamond I would have been home.
Well Gerry is end played at trick one. He knows he'll almost certainly have to open up hearts eventually, so starts with Ace and another heart. Alex wins the Jack discarding a diamond. King of clubs and a finesse back and a diamond lead to Gerry's Ace. Gerry tried a small spade to Q and K. In the end Alex just loses two spades a heart and a diamond. I didn't get one club trick.
In the same set I ended in 4S though Gerry thought about 3N. However looks a good contract especially when Alex led 10D. I could make 12 tricks here. I covered and Rod played the king and I won the Ace. I immediately led a small spade, Alex followed with the 6. It is normal to duck a spade with this holding as you retain control if they don't break, however I don't want to lose a low spade to Rod and have one of my diamond winners ruffed so I went up with the Ace thinking I can duck on the way back. Oh no. I have two discards for my hearts in dummy and I've just removed the only entry. Alex has to win three spade tricks and although I set up my winners in Dummy, he correctly finds heart exits to make sure I can't get discards, 1 down, if only I had played KS first, then AQ clubs, 8D, third diamond. Alex will be stuck and can't stop me getting rid of the heart losers as long as I play KC first when in Dummy with AS.
The reason I am showing the Match Points, we are pair 1 and got 4 points. If I had made 4S, we would still have got 4 points. Funny old game as Jimmy Greaves used to say!